Folks tend to have some pretty serious preferences for pizza. They tend to argue about thick crust verses thin crust, Chicago-style verses New York-style. Everyone has an opinion and most will tend to pretty doggone vocal about which they prefer.
When I went off to college at 17, I lived a mere 45 minutes or less from Chicago. The deep dish pizza at Gino’s and Giordano’s was a new revelation to me with its incredible cornmeal-dusted crust baked in a deep dish pan that almost seemed “fried”. It was stuffed inside-out with loads of chunky fillings and cheese, and because it requires more baking time that would burn the cheese if on top, the uncooked tomato sauce was ladled on top instead and cooked nicely over top of layers of sliced mozzarella cheese. Some of the Chicago places went beyond deep-dish like Giordano’s and added another layer of crust to become truly “stuffed” pizzas. It was love at first bite for me, all those bubbling layers of goodness.
Living in Oklahoma has left a Chicago pizza- sized hole in me to be satisfied so recently when the iron skillet pizza recipes began to surface, I realized that HEY, the iron skillet could easily double for the deep dish pie pan used in Chicago.
Last night I made my first deep dish pie. It was stuffed full of good things like pesto and large chunks of chicken. Trying to lighten things up for myself, I used feta instead of mozzarella and added veggies like mushrooms and red onions and I skipped the top layer of crust.
The result was delicious. I can’t wait to try some other versions, even that cheese laden one some night when I’m feeling a bit naughty…
Pizza dough isn’t really all that difficult to make. I mixed ¾ cup of lukewarm water with a tablespoon of active dry yeast and a teaspoon of sugar. (I used the pizza quick version shown in the picture below.) Whisk it for about 20 seconds to get rid of the lumps and then set it aside to let the yeast activate. Set a timer for 5 minutes.
While that’s working, take your mixer and using beaters or the paddle attachment, fluff 2 ¼ cups of flour with a teaspoon of salt just to mix it up. If your preference is a wheat crust, use ¾ cup wheat flour and 1 ½ cups white flour.
When your 5 minute timer goes off, you should now have a foamy mixture in your water/yeast bowl.
Pour it into your flour mixture with your mixer on low. Also drizzle in 3 tablespoons of olive oil (extra virgin).
Mix this with your mixer for a minute until you get what is known as“shaggy dough”.
I have a KitchenAid mixer, and changed to my dough hook and mixed the dough for 6 minutes more on medium speed. If you don’t have a dough hook, remove the dough and mash it together to form a ball and knead it until it gets smooth.
Then I drizzled a little olive oil into a large (non-metal) bowl and brushed the olive oil all over the sides of the bowl. I plopped my dough into it and rolled it around to coat it with the olive oil. Next, I covered it with a tea towel (you could also use plastic wrap) and let it rise in a warm place for 45 minutes to an hour.
Next , I drizzled another tablespoon of olive oil or two into my beloved iron skillet and brushed it up the sides of the skillet. I then sprinkle lightly with cornmeal.
I added my dough and “punched it down” with my knuckles and continued to use my knuckles to push the dough outward towards the edges of the pan.
I have no idea if this is the “professional” way to stretch dough but it seemed to work for me. I continued to push it up the sides of the pan.
If a hole tore in the dough, I just pinched it together to fix it. I then let this rise again for about 20 minutes.
Next, I spread the bottom of the crust with ½ cup of prepared basil pesto. Thank goodness I still have lots of homemade pesto in my freezer from last summer’s basil explosion in my herb garden.
If you want to try your hand at making it yourself, click here for my easy recipe.
Since I was using chicken in my pizza, I simply sprinkled two chicken breasts with salt and pepper and sizzled them in another tablespoon of olive oil to brown them on both sides on the stove, about 3-4 minutes per side. Then I transferred my pan to the oven to finish cooking while my dough was rising.
After they were done (about 20 minutes), I cut them in half and sliced them into good size slices.
I also sliced up 2 tomatoes and a couple of slices of red onion.
I generously covered my pesto with the chicken inside my crust.
Then I added sliced red onions.
Then I added sliced cremini mushrooms.
Then I added sliced fresh tomatoes and lightly salted and peppered them.
Then I sprinkled the entire thing with feta cheese crumbles.
Then I brushed the crust still showing with a little olive oil and THEN…
I became immensely excited and impatient because I still had to bake my masterpiece.
I baked my pie at 400º for about 25 minutes. Since ovens vary, you will want your crust to be browned and golden around the edges.
The pizza slid right out of the skillet with a little support from a big spatula right onto my cutting board.
I sliced it up.
It was absolutely delicious. I could only handle one piece of this stuffed and hearty pie.
I am already thinking of new things to try – even with a dessert version soon.
What do you think would be fabulous? Shout it out in the comments below!
Just look at these fabulous recipes other food bloggers participating in Food Network’s Comfort Fest: Pizza have come up with!
The Heritage Cook: Gluten-Free Pizza Crust and Homemade Pizza Sauce
Jeanette’s Healthy Living: Easy Turkey Taco Pizza
Devour: Top 5 Pizzas Without Sauce
Elephants and the Coconut Trees: Pepperoni Pizza Puffs
Weelicious: Pizza Balls
Napa Farmhouse 1885: Pizza with Sun-Dried Tomato, Red Pepper and Corn
Red or Green: Pizza with Green Chile, Chicken and Cheese (Gluten-Free)
Virtually Homemade: Individual Cheese Quesadilla Pizzas
Food for 7 Stages of Life: No Yeast Pizza Dough
In Jennie’s Kitchen: Easy, Homemade Pizza Dough
The Blue Apron Blog: Our Favorite Pizza Toppings
The Sensitive Epicure: Mini Deep Dish Polenta Pizzas (Gluten-Free)
FN Dish: Homemade Pizza Comfort by the SliceIf you like this post, you might like these as well!
|Empire Slice House
I have no idea why I haven’t written about Empire Slice House yet. This buzzing-with-hipsters...
|Cal’s Chicago Style Eatery
SADLY THIS RESTAURANT IS NOW CLOSED. Sometime over Christmas break, and before Mr. Wonderful...
|Humble Pie Pizzeria
Once upon a time, I attended a small private college in Kankakee, Illinois. True story - growing up...
|Crab Rangoon Flatbread Pizza
This is my daughter Kayla and her best friend and roommate Brettley from ORU. One year,...